Are you allowed to bring tinderboxes, logs and raw fishes to Clan wars?

[spydroid37]

My friend's member clan has the idea of each clan member having some raw foods they collected (if they train fishing and bank it all) while some skillers stay behind at the back. The skillers will either be firemakers with a inventory full of logs or medics/cooks with a full supply of food they fished (like trouts and all) and high cooking lvl. The idea is for the clan to have two combat teams; one stays behind and the other goes to the fray. When the first group is dying, the remaining troops run back while the second group comes. the medics will trade the wounded group their cooked fishies and the first group will req assist the medics and cook their raw fishies on the firemakers' newly fmed fires.

The question is, will it work??? If it does, my friend has found a way to use skillers in warfare (and use the food they fished while training that couldn't be sold).

[Hawt Zombie]

Wow, that's a cool idea.

Personally, I can't answer your question yes or no, for I have no experience with it.

But, why not just get the raw fish and stuff and try it?

Nice Idea

[chomama23]

Why not just have everybody bring cooked fish?

There's the same supply either way

[droid3k4]

Cho what ifsomeone could burn a fish? There would be less fish.

[allblacks448]

im not sure, please tell me if i miss understood but cho said to bring cooked fish.

pre cook them

AB448

[Asian Rapini]

....

im pretty sure if you try to start a fire it says "you can't do that here!"

why can't you just bring cooked food?

kinda dumb if you think about it.

[spydroid37]

the reason why it's raw is for the players to resist eating them when they are already losing. that's what my mem buddy said.

and no, the clan isnt wasting money buying food, they use up the food skillers have collected while training their fishing levels. if the food doesn't seem to sell, the skillers get rid of it via clan wars. and the medics will only plan to give one cooked fish per person so they don't waste their 3k trade limit on one dude. that's why the combat players simply req assist to cook their own food. i myself don't have the time to check it out but when i do i'll post if it works unless someone gets here before moi.

[Asian Rapini]

... so basically, you're doing it because your clan members have no self control? huh?

food is food and provides the same hp no matter how long you wait to use it.

i simply don't see the point of adding the extra steps, namely having people there for the sole purpose of req assisting, and having people constantly running back and forth when they could just be eating.

why not cook the food outside cwars, by req assisting there?

[Hawt Zombie]

The request assist is pointless, why not just have the skillers cook the food? Here is the way I picture it:

Say a person fighting runs out of food and manages to get away form the attacker. Then, the skiller can cook up some food and trade it to them.

Everyone is happy.

[allblacks448]

yes but here is where the 3k trade limit steps in and interfers.

if they give 3k worth of fish to one guy then they cant give fish to anyone else.

the way i see it is, the only way is if you have an equal amount of skillers and fighters in your clan.

that is the only way i can think of.

you also have to trust that they can make the right descions.

AB448